The tool has two steps, shown as tabs at the top of the screen.
1. Make a buffer. Students choose one of two methods:
-
Weak acid + its salt. Two sliders set the amounts of HA and the sodium salt NaA (0–40 mmol each). Salt particles drop into the beaker as A⁻.
-
Weak acid + some NaOH. Two sliders set the HA and the NaOH added (0–50 mmol). OH⁻ ions visibly take the H from HA molecules, leaving A⁻ and water. Marks under the slider show half and full neutralisation.
Everything updates as the sliders move. Beside the beaker, students see:
-
the pH and its indicator colour
-
a verdict on whether the mixture is a buffer, with the reason
-
bars showing how much HA and A⁻ is available
-
the A-level calculation, updated live
Preset buttons jump to useful cases, such as "No salt", "Neutralise all" and "Too much NaOH".
2. Test it. The buffer appears next to a comparison beaker: HCl at the same pH (NaOH if the mixture is alkaline) or pure water. Students choose a dose of 1, 2 or 5 mmol and add H⁺ or OH⁻ to both beakers at once. Each dose animates for about a second. Then the following update:
-
the pH readouts, with ΔpH and the factor by which [H⁺] changed
-
reserve bars for A⁻ and HA
-
a one-line account of what reacted in each beaker
-
the shared pH graph
Before the first dose, students are asked to predict which pH will change more.
How it works
The pH is calculated exactly, not from the buffer approximation. The model solves the acid equilibrium, water equilibrium, mass balance and charge balance together. So it stays correct for weak acid alone, for buffers, at complete neutralisation and once strong acid or alkali is in excess.
-
Chemistry: ethanoic acid, Ka = 1.80 × 10⁻⁵ mol dm⁻³ (pKa 4.74), Kw = 1.00 × 10⁻¹⁴, 25 °C, 100 cm³ final volume. Activity effects are ignored.
-
Doses: test additions are treated as concentrated, so the volume does not change.
-
Comparison solution: made fresh with exactly the buffer's starting pH. At pH 4.74 this is only about 0.0018 mmol HCl in 100 cm³.
-
The calculation panel: shows the usual A-level method, [H⁺] = Ka × n(HA) / n(A⁻), using amounts after neutralisation. The displayed pH uses the full model, so the two can differ slightly when one component is small. The panel says when this happens.
What the particles represent. Each symbol is 1 mmol. HA is drawn as an A with a dark H attached; A⁻ carries a minus badge. Drawn H⁺ (red ring) or OH⁻ (purple) means strong acid or alkali left over in excess. The free H⁺ from equilibria is far too small to draw: about 0.002 mmol in a typical buffer. The [H⁺] readout shows it instead. Na⁺ and Cl⁻ are spectators and are hidden unless switched on. Particle motion is illustrative only; it does not model collision rates or reaction speed.
Indicator colours are an approximate universal-indicator scale, used so that pH change is visible at a glance.
Using it in a lesson
The sequence below takes about 30–40 minutes as a projected demonstration with whole-class questioning. Each stage also works on its own as a starter or as an independent task on laptops.
-
Weak acid alone (5 min). Choose "Weak acid + its salt" and press "No salt". 20 mmol HA gives pH 2.72, but only 0.19 mmol A⁻. Ask: what could take up added H⁺? The verdict confirms that this is not a buffer.
-
Make a buffer with salt (5 min). Drag the salt slider up slowly and watch A⁻ arrive. At 20 mmol each, pH = pKa = 4.74. Ask students to predict the pH for "More HA" and "More A⁻" before pressing them, then check with the calculation panel.
-
Make a buffer by partial neutralisation (5 min). Switch method, press "No NaOH", then drag NaOH towards the "half the HA" mark. Ask: what happens if we keep going? Show "Neutralise all" and "Too much NaOH". The verdict explains why neither is a buffer.
-
Predict, then test against HCl (5 min). Return to "Half-neutralise" or "Equal amounts" and press "Test this buffer". Have students commit to the prediction question, such as with mini-whiteboards, before clicking. With 2 mmol H⁺, the buffer changes by −0.09 and the HCl by −3.05.
-
Explain the difference (5 min). Pause on the particle story. In the buffer, each H⁺ joined an A⁻. In HCl, nothing could react, so every H⁺ stayed free. Point to the [H⁺] factor: about ×1.2 for the buffer against about ×1,100 for HCl.
-
Capacity (5–10 min). Switch to 5 mmol and keep adding H⁺. The A⁻ bar empties at 20 mmol, free H⁺ appears in the buffer and its colour turns red. Turn on "Show the whole curve" to see the plateau and the fall. Then go back, press "Small amounts" (4 mmol each) and repeat: the same ratio gives the same pH but much less capacity.
-
Extension. Add OH⁻ instead, compare against pure water, or ask students to design a buffer that resists acid better than alkali, and justify it.
Press A or B on the keyboard to add acid or alkali during a demonstration. Undo and "Start again" let you rerun a step after a prediction.
Misconceptions and questions
Each common misconception below has a specific moment in the tool that challenges it.
Misconception
Where the tool challenges it
A buffer keeps the pH constant.
The pH does change, by small amounts each dose, and it falls sharply once A⁻ runs out.
A weak acid on its own is a buffer.
"No salt" gives almost no A⁻ (0.19 mmol), so nothing takes up added H⁺.
Neutralising all the weak acid makes a buffer.
"Neutralise all" leaves no HA to take up OH⁻; the verdict says it is not a buffer.
Same pH means same behaviour.
The buffer and the HCl start at identical pH, then respond completely differently.
Strong acid means concentrated acid.
The matched HCl is a strong acid but extremely dilute: 0.0018 mmol in 100 cm³.
The pH depends only on the HA : A⁻ ratio, so amounts don't matter.
"Small amounts" has the same pH as "Equal amounts" but runs out after 4 mmol.
Cl⁻ or Na⁺ take part in buffering.
Switch on spectator ions: they arrive with each dose and react with nothing.
Questions to ask
-
Both beakers started at pH 4.74. Why did the same dose change one by 0.09 and the other by 3.05?
-
Which particle removes added H⁺? Which removes added OH⁻? Why must a buffer contain both?
-
Your buffer has more A⁻ than HA. Will it withstand more added acid or more added alkali? Test it.
-
How much H⁺ can a buffer made from 20 mmol of each take before it fails? Predict, then check.
-
Why can't you use the buffer equation when n(A⁻) = 0 or when NaOH is in excess?
-
Why does the pH graph for HCl fall steeply at first and then level off?
Practical tips
-
Projecting: the layout fits a 1280 × 720 screen without scrolling. Use the browser's full-screen mode (F11) for the largest beakers.
-
Options (top right):
-
"Universal indicator" turns the liquid colour on or off.
-
"Spectator ions" shows Na⁺ and Cl⁻.
-
"Ethanoic acid names" replaces HA and A⁻ with CH₃COOH and CH₃COO⁻ in text and equations. The particles keep their A and H labels.
-
Background reading: "How buffers work" opens a short explanation and the full model notes. It's a useful handout for students working independently.
-
Changing the buffer: "Change the buffer" returns to step 1 with the settings kept. Opening "Test it" again starts a fresh comparison.
-
Accessibility: it works with keyboard only. Screen readers hear each result. Users with reduced motion switched on get instant updates instead of animations.
-
Limitations:
-
It models one monoprotic weak acid (ethanoic) at a fixed 100 cm³.
-
It does not cover basic buffers (NH₃/NH₄⁺), dilution or temperature.
-
Doses come in whole millimoles so that every dose maps to whole particles.