Learning objectives
Students should be able to:
-
Calculate an average speed using Δs ÷ Δt.
-
Interpret the gradient of a distance–time graph as a rate of change.
-
Explain how a derivative arises as the limit of average rates over shrinking intervals.
-
Connect a distance function with its velocity function.
-
Derive ds/dt = 3t² for s(t) = t³.
-
Explain why zero velocity at one instant does not imply remaining stationary.
Students should already understand coordinates, gradients and speed calculations. The algebraic sections benefit from familiarity with expanding brackets and working with powers.
Suggested teaching sequence
-
Introduce the paradox
Discuss how a rate can describe a single instant when measuring change normally requires two moments. Collect initial explanations before revealing the idea.
-
Connect motion and graphs
Play the car journey and compare the three movement profiles. Ask students to identify when the car is fastest and justify their answer using the graph’s steepness. Use the two-snapshot examples to calculate average speeds.
-
Shrink the interval
Keep the starting time fixed and reduce Δt. Compare the shrinking distance change with the ratio Δs ÷ Δt. Use the magnified inset to follow changes that become difficult to see on the main graph.
-
Move from secant to tangent
Bring the two graph points together and reveal the tangent for comparison. Emphasise that the secant gradient approaches a limiting value while the interval remains non-zero.
-
Build the velocity graph and explore local behaviour
Ask students to predict the velocity graph before revealing it. Compare the different journeys, then zoom into the cubic graph to see how its tangent approximates nearby changes.
-
Derive the cubic example
Investigate s(t) = t³ at t = 2, where the average rates approach 12 m/s. Work through the algebra one stage at a time, then switch to the general case:
[(t + h)³ − t³] ÷ h = 3t² + 3th + h², for h ≠ 0.
As h → 0, the final two terms approach zero, giving ds/dt = 3t². Use the full-workings view to revisit the sequence.
-
Explore the optional cube connection
Separate the added volume into three face slabs, three edge bars and one corner cube. Relate these to 3x²h, 3xh² and h³. After division by h, the expression approaches 3x².
-
Complete the guided calculation
Students work at t = 3 with h = 0.1 s. The stages establish a starting distance of 27 m, an additional distance of 2.791 m and an average rate of 27.91 m/s, before identifying the limiting velocity of 27 m/s. Established values remain beside the graph; hints and workings support each step.
-
Resolve the zero-velocity paradox and consolidate
Investigate motion from t = 0 to t = h. The average speed is h², which approaches zero. Discuss how v(0) = 0 can coexist with positive velocity at every later time. Finish with the seven challenges and the motion, geometry and algebra summary views.
Teaching tips and misconceptions
-
Height and gradient describe different things. Graph height gives distance travelled; gradient gives its rate of change.
-
A tiny interval still gives an average rate. The derivative is the limiting value, not a particular small-interval calculation.
-
Approaching zero is different from dividing by zero. Keep h non-zero during simplification.
-
A tangent is a local linear approximation. Its prediction becomes more accurate sufficiently close to the chosen point.
-
Zero velocity can be momentary. For s(t) = t³, velocity is zero at t = 0 and positive for every t > 0.
-
The model journeys move forwards, so speed and velocity have the same numerical value. The distance and velocity graphs use different vertical scales and units.
Display and independent use
Use Play, Pause, Step, Replay and the timeline to control explanations and allow prediction time. Select Focus view to enlarge visualisations, or Full screen for projection. Guided calculations and challenges retain their questions alongside the graphs.
Students can work independently using the section menu, reveal buttons, hints and answer feedback. Responses remain during the open session but are not saved after closing or reloading. The teaching activities work offline; external video links require internet access.
Reference
Inspired by Grant Sanderson’s The paradox of the derivative — Essence of Calculus, Chapter 2, from 3Blue1Brown. The original video provides an accompanying explanation and can be used before exploration or afterwards for consolidation.